How spectrum is tested on Step 1

Vignettes name an organism or syndrome and ask for an effective drug, or describe treatment failure and ask which organism was not covered.

workspace_premium Think in gaps

Most spectrum questions are really about a gap: cephalosporins miss enterococci and Listeria, β-lactams miss atypicals, vancomycin misses gram-negatives, aminoglycosides miss anaerobes, and metronidazole misses aerobes.

Coverage of problem organisms

Five organism groups drive most coverage decisions.

Who covers what?MRSAVanc, dapto,linezolid,ceftarolinePseudomonasPip-tazo,cefepime,carbapenem,ciproAnaerobesMetronidazole,clindamycin,carbapenemAtypicalsMacrolide,doxy, quinoloneEnterococcusAmpicillin,vancomycin
Problem organisms. Ertapenem is the carbapenem that does not cover Pseudomonas or Acinetobacter.
DrugMRSAPseudomonasAnaerobesAtypicals
VancomycinYesNoC. difficile (oral)No
Piperacillin-tazobactamNoYesYesNo
CeftriaxoneNoNoPoorNo
CefepimeNoYesNoNo
MeropenemNoYesYesNo
CiprofloxacinNoYesNoYes
LevofloxacinNoYesNoYes
AzithromycinNoNoNoYes
DoxycyclineOftenNoNoYes
ClindamycinVariableNoYesNo
MetronidazoleNoNoYesNo
LinezolidYesNoNoNo

Moxifloxacin adds some anaerobic coverage but loses reliable Pseudomonas activity.

Spectrum width

Spectrum runs from narrow agents aimed at one group to broad agents that hit almost everything.

BroaderNarrowPenicillin G, nafcillin, metronidazole, vancomycinModerateAmoxicillin, cefazolin, ceftriaxone, doxycyclineBroadPip-tazo, cefepime, fluoroquinolonesVery broadCarbapenems (meropenem, imipenem)
Spectrum width. Start broad when the patient is septic, then de-escalate to the narrowest drug once cultures return.

Empiric choices by syndrome

Empiric therapy covers the usual organisms for a syndrome and setting.

SyndromeLikely organismsTypical empiric choice
Outpatient community-acquired pneumoniaS. pneumoniae, atypicals, H. influenzaeAmoxicillin or doxycycline; macrolide where resistance is low
Inpatient CAP (non-ICU)Same + more resistant organismsCeftriaxone + azithromycin, or a respiratory fluoroquinolone
Bacterial meningitis (adult)S. pneumoniae, N. meningitidisCeftriaxone + vancomycin (+ ampicillin if > 50 or immunocompromised)
Uncomplicated cystitisE. coliNitrofurantoin, TMP-SMX, or fosfomycin
Cellulitis without pusStreptococciCephalexin or cefazolin
Purulent cellulitis or abscessS. aureus including MRSADrainage ± TMP-SMX or doxycycline
Intra-abdominal infectionEnteric gram-negatives, anaerobesCeftriaxone + metronidazole, or pip-tazo
Hospital-acquired sepsisMRSA, Pseudomonas, resistant gram-negativesVancomycin + pip-tazo or cefepime

Local resistance patterns (antibiograms) change these choices.

DrugCephalosporinsβ-lactams in generalVancomycinAminoglycosidesMetronidazoleDaptomycinDoes not coverEnterococci, Listeria, atypicals, MRSA(most)Mycoplasma, Chlamydophila, LegionellaGram-negatives (too large for porins)Anaerobes (oxygen-dependent uptake)AerobesPneumonia (inactivated by surfactant)vs
Coverage gaps. These gaps explain most "the patient did not improve" questions.

Clinical application

Use gaps to explain failures.

functions Worked example — the meningitis that worsened

A 72-year-old with fever, neck stiffness, and confusion is started on ceftriaxone and vancomycin. CSF culture grows gram-positive rods with tumbling motility. Why did the patient worsen, and what should be added?

  1. Gram-positive rods with tumbling motility point to Listeria monocytogenes.
  2. Listeria is intrinsically resistant to all cephalosporins.
  3. Vancomycin is not reliable for Listeria.
  4. Adults over 50 and immunocompromised patients need empiric Listeria coverage.

Answer. Listeria was not covered. Add ampicillin (TMP-SMX if penicillin-allergic).