How immunodeficiencies are tested on Step 1

Start with the infection pattern, then narrow to the specific defect.

Recurrent infectionsB cellEncapsulatedbacteria,enteroviruses,GiardiaT cellViruses, fungi,PneumocystisPhagocyteCatalase +organisms, abscessesComplementNeisseria (C5–C9)
Infection patterns. T-cell defects often produce combined problems because B cells need T-cell help.

B-cell and T-cell defects

Compare the most-tested syndromes.

DisorderDefectKey findings
Bruton XLABTK; X-linked recessiveBoys; absent B cells, all Ig ↓, small tonsils and lymph nodes
Selective IgA deficiencyMost common primary immunodeficiencyOften asymptomatic; sinopulmonary and GI infections; anaphylaxis to blood products containing IgA; associated with celiac disease
Common variable immunodeficiencyB-cell differentiation defectLow immunoglobulins, often diagnosed in adolescence or adulthood; ↑ autoimmunity and lymphoma
DiGeorge syndrome22q11.2 deletionAbsent thymic shadow, hypocalcemia, conotruncal heart defects, facial features
Hyper-IgE (Job) syndromeSTAT3; Th17 deficiencyCold staphylococcal abscesses, retained primary teeth, eczema, high IgE, coarse facies

Memory aid for DiGeorge (CATCH-22): Cardiac defects, Abnormal facies, Thymic hypoplasia, Cleft palate, Hypocalcemia, chromosome 22.

Combined immunodeficiencies

These affect both T- and B-cell function.

SCIDIL2RG (X-linked) or ADA deficiency; all infectiontypes; stem cell transplantWiskott-AldrichWAS gene, X-linked; thrombocytopenia (smallplatelets), eczema, infectionsAtaxia-telangiectasiaATM DNA repair defect; ataxia, telangiectasias, IgA↓, AFP ↑, lymphomaHyper-IgM syndromeMost often CD40L defect; no class switching; IgM ↑,IgG/IgA/IgE ↓
Combined defects. Avoid live vaccines in children with SCID or other significant T-cell defects.

Phagocyte and complement defects

Abscesses without pus or with catalase-positive organisms point to phagocytes.

Chronic granulomatous diseaseNADPH oxidase defect (mostly X-linked)No respiratory burstCatalase-positive infectionsGranulomasAbnormal DHR flow cytometryLeukocyte adhesion deficiencyCD18 integrin defect (type 1)Neutrophils cannot leave vesselsDelayed umbilical cord separationVery high neutrophil countInfections without pusvs
Phagocyte defects. Chédiak-Higashi syndrome (LYST) adds giant granules in neutrophils, partial albinism, and neuropathy.
  • C1 esterase inhibitor deficiency: hereditary angioedema; swelling without hives; low C4; avoid ACE inhibitors.
  • C3 deficiency: severe recurrent pyogenic infections and immune complex disease.
  • C5–C9 deficiency: recurrent Neisseria infections.
  • Early classical pathway (C1–C4) deficiency: increased risk of SLE-like immune complex disease.

Worked example

Let the organism lead you.

functions Worked example — liver abscess in a boy

A 6-year-old boy has had recurrent skin abscesses and pneumonia, and now has a liver abscess growing Staphylococcus aureus. A prior pneumonia grew Aspergillus. Which test is most likely abnormal?

  1. Recurrent infections with S. aureus and Aspergillus suggest a defect in killing catalase-positive organisms.
  2. Catalase destroys the hydrogen peroxide these microbes make, so neutrophils must generate their own reactive oxygen species.
  3. Defective NADPH oxidase prevents the respiratory burst: chronic granulomatous disease.
  4. The dihydrorhodamine (DHR) flow cytometry test shows absent oxidative burst.

Answer. An abnormal dihydrorhodamine test from chronic granulomatous disease (NADPH oxidase deficiency).